Multi-sensor surveillance is an important part of any security surveillance solution; it is after all the foundation of any CCTV configuration where multiple cameras (sensors) are used to cover the areas of interest. The following points are made with reference to the article written in the July 2016 Hi-Tech Security Solutions magazine on 'Multi-sensor surveillance', to clarify where the strengths and weaknesses in multi-sensor surveillance lie, how 4K is a complementary and not competitive technology, and what it might mean to your overall surveillance plan.
The entertainment industry
The industry involves large areas both open and closed, where there are often sizeable crowds and continuous directional movement for specific periods of time. In the event of any incident, there is normally a trigger event, main, or secondary to distract, that requires full overview for situational awareness before using key located camera (sensors) with PTZ optical or HD digital zoom options to monitor and review the event.
More than 50% of the cost of most installations is spent on labour, cabling, switches, conduits and accessories. Therefore, if you can reduce the number of overall camera points in a particular installation by using high resolution cameras or multi-sensor cameras, you will often reduce costs within this environment. The same economies might also apply within the control room where reduced cameras should mean less licences to fund, less screens to watch and therefore less operators.
A multi-sensor camera providing a 360°, 270° or 180° field of view across four or more sensors should be a more cost effective option compared to individually installed and mounted cameras covering the same area.
"An Arecont Vision 180° multi-sensor SurroundVideo Camera"
Fisheye versus multi-sensor
A fisheye camera uses a single sensor, which may be rated from 1.3 MP up to 12 MP, including 4K (8 MP). The lens is the important item, between 1.3 mm and 1.8 mm to provide the fisheye angle of over 180°. It provides an excellent radius of view, 360° mounted on the ceiling or 180° degree on the wall, a total awareness of the scene with recognition out to around 20 m – noting image resolution drops as you move to the outer edges.
A multi-sensor uses a range of sensors from 2 MP, 4K (8 MP), 10 MP or more per sensor in various configurations according to the coverage required. The difference from the fisheye is the focal length of the lens used for each sensor may offer a range from 2 mm to 16 mm depending upon field of view required. A 16 mm lens on a 5 MP sensor provides recognition out to 100 m, five times the fisheye limit. A good example is the Arecont Vision Omni, providing you with a choice of different lenses from 2 mm to 16 mm for four different sensors, giving options for a wide angle directly below the camera, a long range view down one corridor, a shorter range on a second and a full area coverage, all setup on the one camera (270°) mounted on a corner.
The choice of fisheye, multi-sensor and lens options is entirely dependent on what you are trying to achieve and both certainly have a place within the entertainment industry; just remember those outer edges at short distance and the drop in image quality.
Video management software
ONVIF standards do not provide for multi-sensor or fisheye cameras, therefore your NVR or VMS choice is important. Specialised VMS integration must have been completed to ensure the multi-sensors are properly displayed, recorded and licensed. The fisheye cameras can be dewarped (flattened) and provide sectional layouts to assist in the interpretation of what you are seeing. Likewise with the multi-sensor we need to provide a user friendly panoramic view that enables rapid understanding. Most open platform VMS solutions provide this support; with exacqVision we enable full end to end layouts, the ability to digitally zoom, separate views for detailed use across several operators and all combined with mapping overlays on one single licence for four sensors thus further reducing cost.
The DVTel Latitude mentioned in the article as a VMS option for the DVTel 4K cameras is equally as capable of integrating certain high end multi-sensor cameras such as Arecont Vision’s range of SurroundVideo cameras. Why consider closed VMS/NVR options when there are a number of open-architecture VMS platforms that will provide you with best of breed camera choices.
PTZ cameras versus HD cameras
The often said comment about PTZ cameras is that they are ‘always looking at the wrong place when the event happens’; hence the rise of high definition or megapixel cameras. A PTZ (pan, tilt and zoom) camera features a 360° rotational panning ability for horizontal movement, downward and upward tilt for vertical movement and a lens that, depending upon optical focal range, will provide x10, x20, x30 and even x36 zoom options. The zoom relating to the minimum and maximum focal point; from say 3.6 mm – 108 mm thus providing a x30 zoom (3.6 mm x 30 = 108 mm).
One aspect of the PTZ not yet mentioned is the sensor which often determines the frame rate and resolution for that camera.
The HD camera or sensor will start at 1 MP (720p) using a 1/3-inch or ½-inch sensor and according to resolution requirements and lens options may increase up to 1-inch with the resultant improvement in megapixel resolution, but often a reduction in frame rate. With the correct lens we should be able to provide the same digital zoom as the PTZ camera, but obviously without the pan and tilt as the HD camera would be fixed. We could then capture the same key events, assuming it happened within the field of view, but would obviously require more cameras/sensors to cover the same area as the PTZ; hence the multi-sensor option.
"AV SurroundVideo Omni 270° covering 4 different views simultaneously"
Storage, frame rate and databases
An entertainment venue requires a solution that is correctly planned and well understood to cover all eventualities. Arecont Vision has an excellent reputation for multi-sensor cameras that work in conjunction with their large range of megapixel HD cameras to provide an end to end solution for entertainment venues as can be attested to in the Case Studies on their website and the different VMS platforms they can integrate with.
Working on a casino floor with gambling tables requires the right trade-off between frame rate, resolution and image quality. A multi-sensor camera will capture the quality image of the person or associated persons involved as an overview to an event, despite its lower frame rates.
However, the sleight of hand that deceives the eye needs to be caught on camera using far higher frame rates such as the 4K camera. It is a balance between covering the overall area in sufficient detail and backing it up with higher frame rate cameras over the tables, flooding the area with multiple resolution cameras can often slow down the ability to review all information quickly and substantially increase data rates for both storage and playback reviews.
Understanding the capabilities that each camera/sensor provides, their frame rate, data streaming rate and how much storage space they require is entirely relevant to ensuring that all evidence is correctly captured. A 4K camera is four times the resolution of a 1080p (2 MP) camera and data throughput is an important calculation for all cameras/sensors planned to be used.
This ensures that when VMS operators replay the relevant images from our different camera solutions, we have the footage at the right resolution and frame rate to build the case. The bookmarking and case study applicable to our exacq VMS analysis providing playback based on time criteria, thumbnail searches to pick up key colours or movement, and finally smart searching for key items or specific video areas of interest. Having collated the case study information we can now provide a report with full video and audio details at the same resolution and layout as originally seen.
The Hi-Tech Security Solutions article provided a great introduction for multi-sensor commentary with some knowledgeable and well-founded points. To my mind, the discussion is not about competition from 4K (8 MP) cameras/sensors, but how they can integrate and benefit the entertainment industry working in conjunction with multi-sensor surveillance. You will find that DVTel’s Latitude integrates the Arecont Vision multi-sensor product range alongside their own 4k cameras, providing you with the best of both worlds.
Consider that it is nearly impossible to cover all open areas with PTZ cameras as you require operators for each operation and placing them ‘on tour’ does not resolve threat issues. Replacing those PTZ cameras with multi-sensor cameras now offers you the exact same licence fee cost and ensures a wider area of coverage. Integrate your 4K cameras at hot spots together with other applicable megapixel cameras to provide more detail over a larger area and reduce on total numbers of cameras needed. Ensure that your critical points are fully covered with cameras that record to the frame rate, resolution and detail required onto your enterprise level VMS platform and you should have 99% of all issues covered.